# MakeASong Review A credit-based AI song generator that turns a text prompt or your own lyrics into two full vocal takes per request. ## Editor's Score: 68/100 Capability lands at 17 because MakeASong does one thing cleanly (idea to two-take song) but lacks stem export, arrangement controls, BPM or key settings, and voice cloning that multiple named competitors offer. Ease of use scores 21 because the credit model is transparent, the free tier requires no card, and the tool navigation is simple enough for a non-musician to use in minutes. Value scores 20 because $9.90/month for roughly 100 songs is genuinely competitive, and the credit-refund-on-failure policy is buyer-friendly. Delivery drops to 10 because no user sentiment data could be found for makeasong.io specifically, commercial licensing terms are absent from the pricing page, and the social media presence appears nonexistent, all of which make it difficult to verify that the tool delivers on its claims at scale. ## Pros - Every request returns two full takes from two different models at no extra cost, giving you a real comparison rather than a single output to accept or reject. - The credit system is genuinely fair: failed generations refund credits in full, pack credits last 365 days, and the platform burns soonest-expiring credits first. - The Basic plan at $9.90/month delivers roughly 100 songs, which undercuts one-time pack pricing and makes the subscription the obvious choice for anyone generating more than a handful of songs per month. ## Cons - No stem export, BPM control, key selection, or arrangement editing of any kind. The output is a finished file and nothing else, which is a hard ceiling for anyone with production intent. - The free tier's 80 welcome credits cover only about 6 songs before the account is empty, and there is no daily credit refresh on the free plan the way some competitors offer. - Commercial licensing terms are not prominently disclosed on the pricing page, leaving it unclear whether downloaded songs can be used in monetized content, ads, or client work without a paid plan. ## Pricing Freemium. A free tier is available. - Free: $0 - Basic: $9.90/month - Pro: $29.90/month - Mini Pack: $5.90 - Standard Pack: $14.90 - Large Pack: $39.90 Pricing reflects what we saw at the time of review (2026-11). Confirm current pricing on the official site. Category: AI Voice, Audio & Music (https://aitoolseekers.com/category/ai-voice-audio-music) Official site: https://makeasong.io/ Last verified by a human: 2026-11-11 Reviewed by a human at AI Tool Seekers, a hand-reviewed AI tools directory. Every listed tool is verified by a person before publishing. Scores are editorial opinions from a fixed rubric (capability, ease of use, value, delivery on promise) and cannot be bought; there is no pay-to-rank. Directory: https://aitoolseekers.com This review: https://aitoolseekers.com/tools/makeasong Methodology: https://aitoolseekers.com/how-verification-works ## Verdict MakeASong is the right pick for someone who wants a finished, shareable song from a single sentence with no music knowledge required. The dual-take model is genuinely useful, but the tool offers almost no control over arrangement, structure, or stems, which puts it behind more production-oriented rivals for anyone who wants to shape the output. If you need voice cloning, audio mastering, or stem exports, look elsewhere. Best for: Casual creators, gift-givers, and podcasters who want a complete song fast Not for: Musicians or producers who need arrangement control, stem exports, or commercial licensing clarity ## Overview MakeASong is a web-only AI song generator built around one clear idea: put a sentence in, get two complete songs out. Every request runs through two models, MAS Pro and MAS Wild, and returns two full-length vocal takes so you can pick the one that landed better. The 12-credit-per-request pricing is flat across both models, which removes the guesswork of tiered quality gates that plague some competitors. The tool covers more ground than its homepage suggests. Beyond the core idea-to-song generator, it offers a lyrics-to-song mode for users who already have words written, an AI rap generator with beats, a pure instrumental generator, an AI song cover tool that re-styles existing tracks, and a lyric video maker that syncs text to audio. Free text tools, including a lyrics generator, band name generator, and song title generator, require no account at all. What MakeASong does not offer is equally important to understand. There is no stem export, no arrangement editor, no BPM or key control, and no vocal cloning. The output is a finished audio file, not a set of building blocks. That is a deliberate product choice, not an oversight, and it defines exactly who this tool is and is not for. The credit economy is straightforward and buyer-friendly: failed generations return credits in full, pack credits last 365 days, and the system burns the soonest-expiring credits first so nothing paid-for goes to waste. ## Who should use it MakeASong fits people who have a song idea but no path to record it: someone writing a birthday tribute, a podcaster who needs a custom intro, a teacher building a classroom jingle, or a hobbyist songwriter who wants to hear their lyrics sung back before committing to a full production. The free tier's 80 credits let you test the output quality before spending anything, and the $9.90 Basic plan covers roughly 100 songs a month, which is more than enough for occasional personal use. If you need to export stems, clone a specific voice, master audio to broadcast standards, or produce music with precise BPM and key settings, MakeASong will frustrate you. Waveroom Mastering is the better call for anyone whose primary need is polishing existing audio to a professional standard. ElevenLabs is the right tool if voice quality and voice cloning are the core requirement rather than song generation. ## FAQ Q: How many songs do I get for free before paying? A: New accounts receive 80 welcome credits. Each song request costs 12 credits and returns two takes, so the free tier covers approximately 6 requests. Welcome credits do not expire, but there is no daily refresh once they are gone. Q: What is the difference between the Basic plan and the Standard credit pack? A: Both give you 600 credits (~100 songs), but the Basic plan costs $9.90/month while the Standard pack costs $14.90 as a one-time purchase. The pack is 34% more expensive per credit but has no recurring charge and lasts 365 days, making it better for infrequent use. Q: What are MAS Pro and MAS Wild? A: These are MakeASong's two underlying generation models. Every request runs through both at the same 12-credit cost and returns one take from each, so you always have two distinct interpretations to compare. The pricing page does not detail the technical differences between the two models. Q: Can I use generated songs commercially? A: The pricing page does not explicitly state commercial licensing terms for each tier. This is worth confirming directly with MakeASong before using generated tracks in paid client work, monetized video, or advertising. Q: What happens if a song generation fails? A: Credits are held during generation and returned in full if the request does not complete. You are only charged the 12 credits for requests that finish successfully. Q: Can I top up credits while on a subscription plan? A: Yes. Credit packs can be purchased on top of any active subscription. The system uses plan credits first (since they expire at month end) before drawing from pack credits, which last 365 days.